We’ve mentioned Benjamin Millepied, the dance choreographer for Black Swan, on the site before but I didn’t expect this. According to In Touch, by way of Just Jared, Natalie and Benjamin are dating.

“She has been subletting Sarah Michelle Gellar’s apartment and she wanted to celebrate the New Year with a few close friends and introduce them to Ben,” an insider tells In Touch. “They have actually been a couple since the fall, but she wanted to see how serious it was before she started to show him off to her inner circle. She really likes him.”

Hmmm…