Another example of “has the world gone mad?” – American Hindu’s are expressing their grievances about Devendra Banhart’s Carmensita video, for its “mocking of Hindu concepts and symbols”. Of course their anger is primarily directed at the writer and director of the video. If not them then surely the musician who commissioned and stars in it, Devendra. Right?


They’ve decided to go after Natalie and are demanding a public apology.

This kind of attention seeking political correctness really gets on my nerves. Whether the music video was intentionally poking fun at their religion or not (and personally I doubt there was any mean spirited intention), the makers of the video are perfectly within their rights to do so.

Focusing their argument on one of the actors, Natalie, simply because doing so will get their hissy fit in the news, is as cynical as it gets.

Here is the full article from Contact Music.

NATALIE PORTMAN has upset America’s leading Hindus with her portrayal of an Indian princess in ex-boyfriend DEVENDRA BANHART’s new CARMENSITA video – and they’re calling for a public apology from her.

Religious scholars have called the actress’ role of Princess Carmensita Saplingita in the promo “denigrating” to Hinduism, claiming it “mocks Hindu concepts and symbols”.

Acclaimed Hindu and Indo-American statesman Rajan Zed admits he is deeply hurt by the video, which he claims simply serves to feed incorrect stereotypes of his religion.

He says, “The images used in the video are revered in Hinduism and are not to be thrown around loosely for dramatic effects.
“We invite Hollywood to immerse itself in Hinduism, but we ask that actors and actresses, directors and producers take our religion seriously and respectfully.

“Hindus would gladly provide genuine Hollywood seekers the resources they needed for their study and research. Casual flirting sometimes results in pillaging serious spiritual doctrines and revered symbols and hurting the devotees.”

And he is not alone in calling for a public apology from Portman – officials at the Hindu Alliance of India, Shri Ramayan Pracharini Sabha, India Heritage Panel, have also demanded she distance herself from the Banhart video.

Zed adds, “Forgiveness is one of the main virtues of Hindu ethics. If Natalie Portman offers a sincere public apology, Hindus would not only absolve her but might also pray for her success in future ventures.”